Beyond the
cellphone-ban count.
A policy can require districts to write rules without requiring one statewide ban. It can cover every grade while restricting only classroom time. And a law can pass well before schools must put it into practice.
What this comparison measures
Each finding classifies elementary, middle and high school separately, then shows timing, exceptions and whether the rule also reaches school-issued technology. Districts may adopt stronger local rules than the statewide requirement.
26 published findings use the full-school-day category for elementary school, compared with 23 for high school. Illinois and Maryland are shown separately because the requirement starts later. These are descriptions of the cited policies, not a score of which state is stricter.
Grade bands change the answer
Florida’s policy distinguishes elementary and middle school-day restrictions from high-school instructional-time restrictions. Hawaii’s policy announcement also describes different treatment by grade. A single “state has a ban” label would hide what older students experience.
Georgia’s measure adds a timing difference: its high-school expansion starts later than its K–8 requirement. The tracker therefore keeps present scope and future changes separate.
A local-policy requirement is not one uniform rule
New Mexico’s law requires a local policy but makes an instructional-time prohibition one option, not a statewide command. California, Arizona and Minnesota also leave important choices to local boards.
For school leaders, the practical question is two-part: what must the state policy contain, and what did the local board adopt?
Dates and exceptions matter
“Instructional day” can include transitions, recess and meals; “instructional time” can be narrower. Policies also commonly include disability, health, safety, academic-use and parent-communication exceptions.
Maryland’s policy separates its legal effective date from its 2027–28 school implementation requirement. The briefs show both so a future change is not presented as current classroom practice.
How to use these findings
Start with the grade band, then check who makes the final decision, when the rule begins and which exceptions apply. Follow the source before using a finding for compliance or a local policy decision.